Westport Independent underwhelms. Pony Island surprises. Oxenfree and The Witness kind of get reviews that say, play it if you're going to play it so you can enjoy the experience for yourself first-hand.
That Dragon Cancer gets an interesting review as it's obviously a difficult biographical topic (fatal childhood cancer) and the game design needs to be set against the obvious pain of its designers.
Dragon's Dogma: Dark Arisen gets an approving review but its not clear to me whether this is an RPG or an action RPG. The mention of Monster Hunter indicates the latter.
Aviary Attorney is good, which is a relief as I do want to play it at some point. Similarly Homeworld: Deserts of Kharak and American Truck Simulator.
XCom 2 gets a rave review but I'm not sure I really feel the X-Com games.