The Hobbit Films

60 thoughts
last posted Dec. 31, 2013, 6:32 a.m.

15 earlier thoughts

0

The way the deus ex machina of the Eagles was portrayed is going to give rise to more of the "why didn't the Eagles just carry them all the way?" criticism where in the book, it's made perfectly clear why the Eagles got involved when they did and why they didn't do more.

It's frustrating when a film adaptation opens a plot hole that the book was careful not to. Maybe the second film will explain that but I'm not hopeful.

44 later thoughts